哲学社会科学版
陕西师范大学学报(哲学社会科学版)
马克思主义文论研究
重审马克思主义的“政治批评”:问题与意义
PDF下载 ()
李西建, 谭诗民
(陕西师范大学 文学院, 陕西 西安 710119)
李西建,男,陕西大荔人,陕西师范大学文学院教授,博士研究生导师。
摘要:
“政治批评”作为马克思主义具有鲜明意识形态内涵及实践性的批评话语,它贯穿于20世纪马克思主义文论发展的不同时期,也影响了现代中国文论知识形态的创构,对建立当代具有公共性的文论“政治批评”话语体系具有重要作用。经典马克思主义所创立的是一种“元政治批评”,它从哲学方面确立了“政治批评”的基本属性、价值功能及作为思想方法的特定内涵,具有理论指导的普遍性;后马克思主义所倡导的“政治批评”既有伊格尔顿、詹姆逊等对马克思“元政治批评”的深化和丰富,也有拉墨在文化维度对“政治批评”的现实反思及探索,呈现出理论的多元性与开放性;在新时代社会文化语境下,如何发挥马克思主义“政治批评”的主导作用,总结中国文论的历史经验,吸收马克思“政治批评”的思想精髓及核心理念,对建立具有人类共同体思想的“理论及批评”话语体系有重要理论价值和实践意义。
关键词:
政治批评; 原典性; 文化维度; 现代中国文论; 话语体系建构
收稿日期:
2018-01-16
中图分类号:
A81;I0
文献标识码:
A
文章编号:
1672-4283(2018)05-0052-09
基金项目:
国家社会科学基金项目“当前文学理论知识生产与创新研究”(12BZW005)
Doi:
Reexamination of Marxist “Political Criticism”: Issues and Significance
LI Xijian, TAN Shimin
(School of Chinese Language and Literature, Shaanxi Normal University, Xi’an 710119, Shaanxi)
Abstract:
As Marxist critical discourse with distinct ideological connotation and practicality, political criticism runs through the different development phrases of Marxist literary theory in the 20th century, and affects the construction of knowledge forms of modern Chinese literary theory. Also, it is equally important to play an important role in establishing a “political criticism” discourse system of contemporary public literary theory. The authors of the present paper hold that classical Marxism in fact created a kind of primitive political criticism, which set up the “political criticism” from the aspects of basic attributes,value function and thinking connotation in a philosophical way. Meanwhile, primitive political criticism serves as a general guideline to theory. Political criticism, advocated by PostMarxism, contains the deepness and richness of primitive political criticism from Terry Eagleton and Fredric Jameson, including the realistic reflection and exploration from “Ernesto Laclau and Chantal Mouffe” and their cultural dimension, and represents the diversity and openness in theories. In the new sociocultural context, making use of the leading role of political criticism, summarizing the historical experience of Chinese literary theory, and absorbing the essence and core of political criticism mark the important theoretical and practical significance in building the “theories and criticism” discourse system of the human community.
KeyWords:
political criticism; primitive standard research; cultural dimension; modern Chinese literary theory; discourse system construction