哲学社会科学版
陕西师范大学学报(哲学社会科学版)
法学研究
以物抵债的解释与构建
PDF下载 ()
王 洪 亮
(清华大学 法学院, 北京 100084)
王洪亮,男,黑龙江海伦人,法学博士,清华大学法学院教授,博士研究生导师。
摘要:
从司法实践中“以物抵债”约定的问题出发,进行类型化研究,可以发现其中不同的价值内容,区分后形成案例群,进而在案例群中发现代替性构成要件。在制度定位上,以物抵债是消灭旧债的替代方式,旧债是其基础;在构成识别上,基本区分代物清偿契约及其履行,进而明确在债务人不履行情况下,债权人可以就原债权进行清偿;在法律效果上,代物清偿可以消灭债务关系,债权人承担使用与变价替代给付的风险,但不承担瑕疵担保之风险,而瑕疵担保责任的承担仍然要根据旧的债之关系进行处理,在依据瑕疵担保责任解除的情况下,旧有债之关系回复。
关键词:
以物抵债; 代物清偿; 代物清偿合同; 瑕疵担保
收稿日期:
2016-05-20
中图分类号:
D923.2
文献标识码:
A
文章编号:
1672-4283(2016)06-0106-10
基金项目:
国家社会科学基金项目“缔约上过失的构成与功能”(15FFX006)
Doi:
Explanation and Construction of the Agreement of Expiation of Debts in Kind
WANG Hongliang
(School of Law,Tsinghua University,Beijing 100084)
Abstract:
Starting from the problem of an agreement of expiation of debts in kind in judicial practice between parties, a classification research will be conducted and the different value contents will be found, then case groups will be formed after the distinguishing, so as to find the substitutive constitutive elements in the case groups. From the view of the function of expiation of debts in kind, it is an alternative of elimination of original debt, which is the foundation of the expiation of debts in kind. As for the constitution, a basic distinction between the agreement of datio in solutum and its performance will be carried out, furthermore, the creditor may be liquidated on the original debt if the debtor does not fulfill its obligation. As for the legal effects, datio in solutum may eliminate the debts, and the creditor may bear the risks of the use and the price. However, a risk of warranty against defects is not necessary, and it will be handled according to the original obligational relationships. The original obligational relationship will revive when the contract will be terminated according to the warranty against defects.
KeyWords:
expiation of debts in kind;datio in solutum;agreement of datio in solutum;warranty against defects