哲学社会科学版
陕西师范大学学报(哲学社会科学版)
哲学研究
心灵的主观性特征与客观性概念
PDF下载 ()
成彬
(中国人民大学哲学院, 北京 100872)
成彬,女,陕西西安市人,中国人民大学哲学院博士研究生。
摘要:
近代以来,哲学对心灵问题的探讨一直难以摆脱主观与客观的矛盾。鉴于以往的心灵观在解决主客观关系问题上的失效,内格尔独辟蹊径地提出心灵理论。内格尔认为,意识经验是一种广泛存在的现象并具有不可还原的“经验的主观性特征”;此外,他主张对心灵进行客观性理解,即“心灵的客观性概念”,从而寻求主观意识经验中的客观性;他甚至强调主观方面具有实在性,并明确提出了“主观实在”概念。内格尔心灵理论的诸多“强”观点不可避免地受到物理主义及其他学派的诘难,但其统合主客观立场的理论倾向开辟了理解心灵的新路径,在意识研究领域具有重要地位。
关键词:
内格尔; 心灵理论; 意识; 主客关系
收稿日期:
2016-05-16
中图分类号:
B712.6文献标识码: A
文献标识码:
A
文章编号:
1672-4283(2016)05-0142-06
基金项目:
Doi:
The Subjective Character and the Objective Concept of Mind
CHENG Bin
(School of Philosophy, Renmin University of China, Beijing 100872)
Abstract:
Since the origin of modern philosophy, philosophers’ investigation of mind has been hindered by the opposition between the subjective and the objective. Considering the failure of past theories to deal with the relation between the subjective and the objective, Nagel proposes his unique theory of the mind. According to Nagel, conscious experience is a widespread phenomenon, and it has an irreducible subjective character of experience. In addition, he also advocates that we should account for the mind from the objective view, i.e., the objective concept of mind, so as to understand the objectivity of subjective conscious experience.Furthermore, he even claims that the subjective aspect of consciousness is real, and therefore puts forward the notion of subjective reality. Inevitably, various strong views of Nagel’s theory of mind are challenged by physicalists and others. Nonetheless, its unique approach of integrating the subjective and the objective standpoints opens new space for our exploration of mind and therefore occupies a significant position in the study of consciousness.
KeyWords:
Nagel; theory of mind; consciousness; the subjectivityobjectivity relation