哲学社会科学版
陕西师范大学学报(哲学社会科学版)
海外学术论坛
西方学者研究中国史的方法
PDF下载 ()
[英]鲁惟一(著)张莉(译)
(剑桥大学 英国 剑桥; 陕西师范大学 西北历史环境与经济社会发展研究院, 陕西 西安 710062)
鲁惟一(Michael Loewe),男,英国著名汉学家,历史学家,剑桥大学荣休教授; 张莉,女,新疆吐鲁番人,理学博士,陕西师范大学西北历史环境与经济社会发展研究院副研究员。
摘要:
西方学者从事中国史的研究是在以下几个重要层面展开的;第一,不同的历史学家基于不同的观念所进行学术研究的目标和学术问题也是不同的。第二,在历史研究中,比较和对照的方法是提出问题,以及将研究结论提升到更具有普遍意义层面的重要途径。第三,对史料本身的文本批评是历史研究的重要步骤。第四,西方历史学家研究中国史面临的主要困境在于历史记录的不完整性、将当代的假设和思想置入历史时期的诱惑和危险、对中国丰富史料的熟悉程度等方面。第五,不同的历史学家有不同的研究意图和方法。最后,西方历史学家研究中国史的未来之路在于对两种相似的文化进行比较研究、关注中国历史上的分裂时期、在分别针对专家学者和其他领域研究者以及普通读者三个层面上进行中国史的写作。
关键词:
西方学者; 中国史研究方法; 史学观念; 历史比较; 历史文本批评
收稿日期:
2014-05-10
中图分类号:
K061,K2
文献标识码:
A
文章编号:
1672-4283(2015)03-0065-10
基金项目:
国家社会科学基金项目(13FZS014)
Doi:
Western Scholars’ Methods of Studying Chinese History
Written by Michael Loewe(UK), Translated by ZHANG Li
(Cambridge University, Cambridge, UK; Northwest Research Institute of Historical Environment and Economicsocial Development,Shaanxi Normal University, Xi’an 710062, Shaanxi)
Abstract:
This paper points out there are several important aspects in Chinese history research for a western scholar. Firstly, the approach of any historian depends on his concept of the function and duty of the historian and the purpose for which he is writing. Secondly, comparison and contrast are the hope of reaching conclusions that are both valid and of a reasonably wide significance. Thirdly, identifying his sources of information and assessing their value are important aspects in historical research. Fourthly, the historian’s difficulties are incomplete information, the temptation to impose the assumptions and ideas of our own time on the past, familiarity with the Chinese sources and so on. Fifthly, different historians have different intentions and methods. Finally, the author points out the way forward: comparing in two cultures, conjointly but independently; paying attention for periods of disunity; presenting the results of research on several levels (professional standard, for colleagues in other disciplines and for general readers).
KeyWords:
western historian; approach to the history of China; concept; comparison; historical writings citicism